the rock smells something cookin'
saw it last night. This is a review from a former hardcore DOOM gamer. You've been warned. Basically let's start it off:
Acting
It's standard fare really. For action/popcorn movies I usually compare the acting ability with either "The Rock" or "Pirates of the Caribbean" since they have fairly entertaining acting. Well to say it's worst that those two gems, but it's not as bad as say....Gone in Sixty Seconds. Each character plays their stock parts well, most noticeable Portman who's just a slimy sumbitch. As mentioned before there are parts where the actors HAM IT THE FUCK UP. Why isn't because of their lack of ability...but the scene runs long. It just happens really and the gratuitous use of "fuck" as aggression and anger kinda gets aggravating when them emphasize it a bit too much. Just don't expecting to be quoting too much from this film.
Storyline
Hell is removed and mentioned only as a metaphor. It's hinted there is a battle between good and evil due to how the genetic mutation chooses who to infect. But nevertheless its basically the same premise behind Aliens...a special task force sent in to do something, but doesn't know the true reason for the mission.
Action/horror
I did jump a few times where it was pretty obvious I should have expected something, but hey it happens. The action builds up slowly. I thought it was alright because just too much action would bog it down. It's not paced in the best way (it ran long in some parts) but it's to each person's taste. The FPS (first person shooter, for you non gaming geeks) part is basically the money shot that people were waiting for.
FPS part
Surprisingly it does not suck. How they interpret "get into" FPS mode is great. You'd think they'd do it all the time where near the beginning the squad syncs up their cameras, but it doesn't happen until late into the film and it only happens once. It was done very well, as much as the FPS mode would allow, with no complaints here. Regardless of your expectations for something great....don't....it's like watching a monkey at a typewriter; it's not fucking Opera, but it's entertaining.
Monsters
The fight in the pit was pretty awesome as well with the FPS mode. But overall the monsters were pretty good. Sadly being genetic mutations, you could only have so many "humanoid" monsters. No spider demons here. What's a bit of a consistency issue as to how powerful these enemies are. At one point their are ripping heads off, and another then are just punching really hard.
Overall
As an adaptation: I'd place this film right along the same league with Resident Evil. It's not the greatest re telling because it could be a "film on it's own". But don't think of it as an adaptation in the vein of "based on a true story"....think of it is as a "inspired by events".
As a film: It's good. A tad long and drawn out in parts with some really tired and clichéd themes, but nevertheless what action film *doesn't* have that? Be warned...there is a LOT of sneaking in the dark and a few bad puns.